All hail ITV reporter John Ray, as he becomes the news in Beijing
I'm woefully underwhelmed with the article on the Tibet protest in Beijing.
- To cover it was questionable to start with: it just needs a dozen foreigners who'd gone to Beijing with an agenda, and ITV fixes it for them to complete all their ambitions. Well done ITV. Something like 20 milion people in Beijing at this time, and you wanted to publicise the activities of 0.00006% of them. You made that editorial choice only because it fitted to your own agenda too.
- Your report suggests you've seen a Chinese anti-democratic, freedom-repressing activity yes-here-you've-seen-it-here-on-ITV. I have two questions:
- Is the UK the bastion of democratic values? You have to have police permission in UK for a protest, protests are illegal altogether in certain places, and the police will be heavy-handed at certain times.
- Are you a kind of people who respect laws of the countries you visit, or do you only obey UK laws when you're in another country?
- And the arrested reporter, sticking his head out of the police van shouting the odds: had he forgotten that police in Beijing tend to speak Chinese? He has lived in Beijing (apparently) since 2006, but he hadn't learned to say "I am a journalist" in Chinese and hadn't remembered that Chinese people speak Chinese. So that's an achievement, isn't it. Or maybe he was just acting-up for his TV news article, bless him. What do they say when reports "become the news" instead of "reporting the news"? Personally, I think the police officer showed great restraint. I think I'd have punched his lights out.
- And then a prediction about the future, as certain as from a fortune-teller in her caravan: the Chinese nationals will be detained without trial till the end of the Olympics, and the foreigners will be deported. (It's a pity we didn't hear him in Iraq, predicting that 800,000 people would die as a result of an invasion by Britain and the USA, against international law and every international security organisation.) But anyway, that's all so different than the way we do things in the UK, isn't it? Not! Did I miss the way we have same-day trials in the UK? We'd never have a trial 10 days after an arrest, would we? Oh no, we don't even have to charge people for 40 days!!! And British and Europeans never arrest foreigners caught breaking the law and deport them immediately, do they? Oh no.
- And then let's talk about Tibet itself, since that was the subject of the protest. You nicely reported unrest in Tibet when it happened, didn't you. You assumed Senegalese and Tibetan police were Chinese police and army. And then there's the real economic benefits China has brought to Tibet, which you actually perverted to some kind of mal-activity. I ask you - what's the point in using ITV's funds to go abroad? Why not just write the story you want from London, and save your company a lot of money? There's just no point in being on the ground, since you're not hampered by any desire to collect facts.